Passing the Farm to the Next Generation: Fair vs. Equal – Part 2

By Educational Content

Fair Does Not Mean Equal: A Framework for Farm Families

So what does fair actually look like? There is no single answer. But here is a framework that farm families in Lancaster, Chester, Lebanon, and Berks Counties may find useful for working through the dynamics.

Step 1: Separate the Values Conversation from the Asset Conversation

Before anyone discusses acreage, appraisals, or structures, the family needs to discuss values. What does this farm represent? What do the parents want it to accomplish? Is keeping it in agricultural use a priority? Is keeping the family together more important than the financial outcome?

These are not financial questions. They are formation questions. And until they are answered, no financial structure will feel right to everyone involved.

Questions worth discussing as a family:

• What has the farming child contributed that does not appear on a balance sheet?
• What do the non-farming children need to feel to know that they have been treated with dignity?
• Is the goal to keep the farm operating, or is it acceptable for it to be sold eventually?
• How do the parents want to be remembered in the way they handled this?

Getting these answers on the table, in a structured family conversation rather than around a holiday dinner, changes the entire planning process.

Step 2: Understand the Liquidity Challenge Honestly

When the farm represents the majority of the estate, providing equal inheritance to non-farming children may require either selling the farm, burdening the farming child with debt to buy out siblings, or leaving non-farming children with significantly less than their equal share.

Each option presents potential benefits, costs, and tradeoffs that should be evaluated in light of the family’s circumstances. Understanding the liquidity gap honestly before planning begins can shape every decision that follows.

A few considerations worth exploring with your advisory and legal team:

• What is the farm actually worth today, and how does that compare to the rest of the estate?
• Are there other assets, such as life insurance, liquid investments, or other real estate, that may be used to provide inheritance to non-farming children without touching the farm?
• Is there a way to structure a purchase arrangement that gives the farming child time to buy in at a manageable pace without creating financial strain?
• What are the potential tax considerations involved in different transfer approaches, and how might those affect each family member differently?

These are not questions with simple answers. They are starting points for a coordinated conversation between your financial advisor, your estate attorney, and your CPA.

Step 3: Build a Structure That Reflects Your Values, Not Just Your Assets

Once the family has talked through values and the advisory team has mapped the financial picture, the structure follows. There are a range of approaches that farm families have used, and no single approach works for every situation.

Some families choose to transfer the farm to the farming child at a below-market value, with the understanding that the non-farming children will receive other assets or future gifts to cover the difference. This approach requires transparency and a family agreement that everyone genuinely buys into.

Some families use life insurance as a liquidity tool, positioning a policy to provide non-farming children with an inheritance that does not require touching the farm itself. This is worth discussing with your advisor to understand whether it fits your specific situation.

Some families structure a gradual transfer over time, allowing the farming child to purchase the operation in stages while the parents retain income from the land during their retirement years. This approach addresses both the liquidity challenge and the retirement income question simultaneously.

What matters is not which structure you choose. What matters is that the structure reflects what the family actually decided together.

What Happens If You Do Nothing

The cost of avoiding this conversation is real and worth naming plainly.

Without a plan, the default is often equal division. And equal division of an illiquid farm among multiple heirs may increase the risk of a sale, financial strain, or family conflict that outlasts the estate settlement by decades.

Farmland that took generations to build may get sold in a probate proceeding. A farming child who gave the best years of their life to the operation may walk away with a fraction of what they contributed. Siblings who never intended to cause harm may end up on opposite sides of a legal dispute.

You worked too hard and cared too much for that to be the ending.

Start the Conversation Before You Have To

If you are a farm family in Lancaster County, Chester County, Lebanon County, Berks County, or the surrounding areas, and this question is somewhere in the back of your mind, consider starting the conversation before an unanticipated transition creates urgency.

At Bare Wealth Advisors, we work alongside families navigating exactly this kind of transition. We serve families with investable assets across a wide range of circumstances, as well as high-net-worth families managing complex farm and business succession situations that require deep coordination across financial, legal, and tax disciplines.

After more than 25 years working with agricultural families in this region, we understand the weight of this decision. Certain members of our team also come from farming families. We understand that the farm is not just a financial asset. And through intentional planning, as part of an advisory relationship, we aim to help you work toward a plan that honors everyone involved and leaves the legacy your heart desires.

Click here to schedule a complimentary discovery meeting. 

Bring your questions. We will bring the experience to work and carefully work through them.

Frequently Asked Questions